Where to Drink in Brookhaven, New York
17 bars listed in Brookhaven, New York.
25 Montauk Highway, E Main St and Harbor Walk appear in the Brookhaven listings.
Benchwarmer's Tavern and Grill at 23 NY-25A, Buffalo Wild Wings at 385 Route 25A and Buffalo Wild Wings at 999- 25 Montauk Highway.
Brookhaven's recorded types: 5 sports bars, 3 pubs and beer bars and 2 lounges.
For the full list with filters and a map, open all bars in Brookhaven.
Last updated November 21, 2026
Places to Start
By Type
Questions
- How many bars are listed in Brookhaven?
- Our directory currently lists 17 bars in Brookhaven, from Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap and available public liquor license records. This is a directory count, not a claim that every operating bar has been found.
- What kinds of bars are listed in Brookhaven?
- Recorded types include sports bars (5), pubs and beer bars (3), lounges (2) and gay bars (1). A type is shown only when it is present in our data.
- Are hours available for every bar?
- No. Hours appear only where we have recorded hours. Missing hours do not mean a bar is closed, and published hours may change.